Homes for Sale in Fair Haven, NJ

Explore homes for sale in Fair Haven, NJ, right here on this page. Fair Haven is one of the Eastern Monmouth County communities Theresa Nesci knows well, and that local knowledge supports every step of buying or selling here, from a first purchase to a next move. Browse the current listings below to find a home that fits what you're looking for in Fair Haven.

Market snapshot

• Active listings: 8
• Median list price: $1,497,500
• Median days on market: 32
• Updated: 2026-10-15

Current listings

• 18 Locust Avenue, Fair Haven — $699,999 (3 bd, 1 ba, 840 sqft)
• 9 McCarter Avenue, Fair Haven — $999,000 (2 bd, 1 ba, 804 sqft)
• 547 River Road, Fair Haven — $1,495,000 (4 bd, 3 ba, 2,140 sqft)
• 259 3rd Street, Fair Haven — $1,499,999 (4 bd, 4 ba)
• 69 Harvard Road, Fair Haven — $3,799,000 (5 bd, 5 ba)
• 133 Park Road, Fair Haven — $3,200,000 (5 bd, 5 ba, 3,200 sqft)
• 25 Buttonwood Drive, Fair Haven — $3,295,000 (5 bd, 5 ba, 3,200 sqft)
• 807 River Road, Fair Haven — $1,250,000 (2,565 sqft)

Listing information courtesy of MOREMLS (Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS).

Frequently asked questions

How many homes are for sale in Fair Haven, NJ?

There are 8 active homes for sale in Fair Haven, NJ as of 2026-10-15, based on listing data from the local MLS.

What is the median list price of homes in Fair Haven, NJ?

The median list price of active homes in Fair Haven, NJ is $1,497,500.

How long have homes in Fair Haven, NJ been on the market?

Active homes in Fair Haven, NJ have been listed for a median of 32 days.

How can I see every home for sale in Fair Haven, NJ?

Use the full home search to browse every active listing in Fair Haven, NJ, save favorites and get alerts when new homes come on the market. Theresa Nesci Real Estate Advisor can also help you schedule showings.

Explore more

• About Fair Haven
• Single-Family Homes for Sale in Fair Haven, NJ

Related articles

• Town-by-Town Guide for First-Time Buyers in Monmouth
• Fair Haven's Value Surge: What It Means